High vs. Low Mileage: What Matters Most When Buying a Used Car?

odometer

When shopping for a used car, one of the first numbers buyers tend to focus on is mileage. It makes sense, mileage gives a quick idea of how much a car has been driven. But the truth is, mileage isn’t everything. A low-mileage car isn’t always the better buy, and a high-mileage vehicle isn’t necessarily a risky choice. So what really matters when comparing high vs. low mileage in used cars? Let’s break it down.

What Does “Mileage” Really Tell You?

Mileage refers to the number of kilometers (or miles) a vehicle has driven since it left the factory. Generally, the higher the mileage, the more wear and tear the vehicle has experienced. But this is just part of the picture. How a vehicle has been driven, maintained, and stored can have just as much, if not more, impact on its condition.

The Pros of Low Mileage Cars

Low mileage can be appealing because:

  • Less wear and tear: Fewer kilometers often mean the engine, suspension, and brakes haven’t been pushed as hard.

  • Higher resale value: These cars tend to hold value a bit better.

  • Potential for longer future use: If properly maintained, the car might have many more years ahead.

However, low mileage doesn’t automatically mean “better.” A car that sits idle for years can develop problems with seals, gaskets, batteries, and tires. So it’s important to look beyond the odometer.

The Upside of High Mileage Cars

High mileage vehicles, especially those with 150,000 km or more, are often passed over by buyers, but that can be a mistake. Here’s why:

  • Better price point: High mileage cars typically cost less, offering more value for budget-conscious buyers.

  • Proof of reliability: If a vehicle has made it to 200,000+ km and is still running well, that’s a strong indicator of build quality and consistent maintenance.

  • Well-maintained history: Many high-mileage vehicles come with detailed service records and a clean bill of health.

Maintenance > Mileage

The biggest factor in any used car purchase is how well the vehicle has been cared for. A high-mileage car that’s had regular oil changes, fluid flushes, brake services, and inspections may outperform a low-mileage car that was neglected.

Ask to see service records, check the condition of the tires and brakes, and look for signs of rust or fluid leaks. A professional mechanic’s inspection is always a smart investment, no matter the mileage.

Highway vs. City Kilometers

Another factor to consider is how the kilometers were accumulated. Highway driving is generally gentler on a car than city driving, which involves more stop-and-go traffic, braking, and idling. A vehicle with high highway mileage might be in better shape than a lower-mileage car driven mainly in urban areas.

Age Matters Too

A 10-year-old car with 60,000 km may seem like a steal — but if it hasn’t been driven regularly or stored properly, it could have hidden issues. On the flip side, a newer car with high mileage might have all the latest features, safety tech, and a drivetrain that’s just getting warmed up.

Final Verdict: Balance is Key

Instead of focusing solely on the odometer, look at the whole story of the car:

  • Service history

  • Accident reports

  • Ownership history

  • Mechanical condition

High mileage doesn’t mean “bad,” and low mileage doesn’t guarantee “great.” The sweet spot is often a well-maintained vehicle with moderate mileage, one that’s been driven regularly and taken care of properly.


Looking for a Used Car You Can Trust?

At Bender’s Auto Sales in Listowel, Ontario, every car we sell is inspected and ready for the road ahead.

📞 Contact us: 519-291-3390
📍 Location: 785 Main Street East, Listowel, Ontario